Isn't his father, an Rph, in jail too? I cannot imagine any parent with young kids feeling safe with Caleb Fairley free.

This animal should have been executed for the crimes he committed; however, I do understand Bruce Castor sparing his life in exchange for the location of the bodies to give the family some sense of peace.

Now he wants to waste more taxpayer money on a farce of trial? I just wish he could be locked in a cell with the most violent inmates and have him beat within an inch of his life only to revive him and repeat the process.

ARE YOU KIDDING ME!

READ BELOW , HE DID MORE THAN STRANGLE THE VICTIM. WHY WASTE MORE MONEY ON THIS SLIME BALL. MAY HE ROT IN HELL!!!!!

On September 10, 1995, Fairley was working alone at Your Kidz & Mine, a children's clothing store owned by his parents in Collegeville, Pennsylvania. Just before closing time Lisa Manderach (born September 30, 1965) and her 19-month-old daughter Devon (born February 4, 1994) entered the store.[1] Fairley locked the doors to the store when he realized that they were the only customers present. He then attempted to sexually assault Manderach. When she attempted to resist him, he became enraged and strangled her to death. He also strangled Manderach's infant daughter. After the murder he sexually assaulted Manderach's corpse, before going to an Electric Hellfire Club concert that he had been planning to attend that night

There is no way this guy should ever see the outside of a jail again!

He will not rot in hell. In fact, people do not 'rot' in hell. They vividly experience severe physical and emotional torment and suffering for eternity. Several years ago he trusted Christ as Savior, so he'll spend eternity in heaven. However, that does not excuse him from suffering the consequences of his sin prior to his earthly death and entry into eternity. The argument, at least implied, that a person (not insane or otherwise seriously mentally ill) does not know right from wrong regarding murder and sexual assault, is ludicrous.The proper sentence would have been execution, but since it's life in prison, he needs to be there until he dies.

First article I've ever read here, and I think what this man did was beyond heinous, and I LOVED Bruce Castor's response

Caleb Farley is a creeping little snake and should remain behind bars the rest of his life. There isn't a Judge out there who would grant this animal a new trial.

This is the most absurd and frivolous attempt at a new trial that I have ever heard. His lawyer should be embarrassed at the waste of public resources he is perpetrating.

I agree with Dynamo47. This slime ball and his attorney will "shop for a sympathetic judge" and then he'll be let loose to roam the same streets as we do. His release will be based upon some minor infraction of "his rights" while the dead have none. Believe me they walk among us more than we know or want to admit. Funny how we don't hear about this kind thing happening in other parts of the world. Maybe its because their justice system is quicker or more straight-forward. I'm not necessarily advocating one system over another but perhaps it's time to ask ourselves when is enough enough and when do we, permanently, rid our society of theses criminals?

People need to knock it off making this a political issue. There is no way this sick SOB is getting out of jail. Ever. Comparing this to the Mumia Abu Jamal case is moronic. This guy will get his time in court and be sent right back to the state Pen for the rest of his life.

OH! So he wasn't "crazy" after all! Nice try mom. Knew it all along. Caleb's mother should be in jail as well for allowing this disgusting FAT SLOB to watch the store when SHE KNEW HE WAS DANGEROUS!!!!! ROT IN JAIL LOSER!

If the public knew the incredibly sick & twisted details of these murders, Caleb would pray to be kept in jail where he is somewhat protected! He is a deranged, emotionless, killer. No regard for life & incapable of rehabilitation. His release would soon lead to additional violent rape, mutilation, and murder. The story of that day will haunt me forever!

Bruce Good- PAHLEEEEZE!!! Regarding your statement, "Several years ago he trusted Christ as Savior, so he'll spend eternity in heaven." is an insult and revolting. Many, along with I, would perceive his willingness to be "Born Again " was merely a ploy to TRY to show the courts he has repented and shows remorse. PLEASE!!! And, for him to argue "Fairley argues that, despite the fact that he was 21 at the time of the killings, he should be afforded the same considerations as an offender under the age of 18 because 21-year-olds are still developing adult characteristics" is TOTAL BS. He's only trying to save his own hide. My observations of many "Born Again Christians" is that they are often lost, confused, misled, emotionally troubled, social misfits who become easy prey for brainwashers, such as yourself. That poor woman and her defenseless infant whom he strangled is who you should think of, and not defend this piece of trash. I don't blame Castor AT ALL for saying he'd "Come to court and laugh" if Fairley makes that argument.