The Weather Channel announced Tuesday it will begin naming winter storms.
I will make a prediction this will last one, maybe two winter seasons.
State College, PA based AccuWeather, tells me via Twitter: "@ThreatcoreNews We have explored this issue for 20 years and have decided that this is not good science."
What is your opinion on this? Do we really want a name for every storm? I think not. A winter season such as 2010, would result in name after name. This new naming idea by TWC, uncoupled from the National Weather Service, has the tendency to bring nothing more than increased confusion.
Imagine the disconnect if one broadcast outlet names a storm, and others do not? What about the dynamics of a true winter storm when the criteria no longer meets the naming system? Drop the name and give a new one when it bombs out in the Northeast?
Recall the October snowstorm of 2011. It was modeled days in advance. The European model ECMWF model nailed it from 7 days out. American models missed the storm and it was disregarded and non-reported. When the storm hit, Jim Cantore from the Weather Channel stood there saying how the storm came out of nowhere.
Winter storms are too dynamic to try and play the name game. We survived this long without winter storm names.
Is the naming system a way to get ratings, or an attempt to save lives?
Dr Steven Greene
10:03 am on Wednesday, October 3, 2012
It would seem to be, as you allude to, a media tactic, but if it can raise awareness of a danger it may be worth it. Sometimes people underestimate the danger in these storms....
Dot
2:53 pm on Wednesday, October 3, 2012
I can see where this may be helpful to differentiate between "this" storm that's on its way out of the area from "that" storm that is coming on its heels. I don't understand why they couldn't come up with an actual name rather than naming one "Q" after a NY subway stop! What?!
Dr Steven Greene
4:15 pm on Wednesday, October 3, 2012
Do they have a preset list of names?
Tom Bartman
9:56 pm on Wednesday, October 3, 2012
They sure do. Here's the list:
http://i.imwx.com/common/articles/images/naming-winter-storms_650x366.jpg